Inclusive history

Inclusive history

INHIST builds on existing approaches to inclusive history but goes further by challenging the traditional majority–minority framework. It introduces “polyphonic inclusivity” as an approach that recognizes the agency and equal validity of multiple, diverse, and often entangled historical voices, without reducing them to a single dominant narrative.

Concept of Polyphonic Inclusive History

Kateřina Čapková

The term inclusive or integrated history is used variously in historiography. In Holocaust studies, Saul Friedländer advocated an integrated approach to research on World War II, which he understood as combining the perspectives of perpetrators and victims, of political history and the history of ideology on the one side, with the perspective of social history on the other (Friedländer 1997–2007; Wiese, Betts 2010; Garbanini, Jaskot 2018). Inclusive history most commonly means that a previously marginalized region moves into a dominant narrative (e.g. Rutar 2014). Historiography on inclusive history has been also decisively inspired and strengthened by feminist approaches that have highlighted women’s historical agency (e.g. Betti at al. 2022). Close to our approach are also texts written by teachers or scholars in didactics from areas with a history of discrimination against parts of the (indigenous) population, such as Australia, the USA, South Africa, and Canada. Even if multiple studies establish that students who have access to a culturally responsive curriculum are more academically engaged and that the education provides them with cognitive tools needed to combat institutional racism (Bryan-Gooden et al. 2019), curricula in many schools remain problematic on this count. Alongside the history of marginalized groups, which is still often inadequately taught, students are, for instance, constantly confronted with the dominant historical narrative, for example in Australia with terms such as terra nullius and that the country was discovered (Weuffen 2022). Other teachers offer model lessons to stimulate discussion about interpretations of history that are still dominated by white men and eurocentrism (Edmondson 2023). The need for inclusive history has also been highlighted by protests following the murder of George Floyd and attacks on statues of colonizers or slave traders (Naidu-Silverman 2020). Thus, case studies from the history of enslaved people have been published out of the feeling that inclusion of underrepresented history in public history became a moral imperative (see e.g. Worthington 2021). In some sub-themes, the commitment of charismatic individuals has helped to improve the situation. For example, David Olusoga, a British historian, writer, and filmmaker, has succeeded in integrating the historical experience of Black British more into the dominant narrative of British history through several successful TV series and his popular book (Olusoga 2016; see also Otele 2020). At the same time, however, he emphasizes that he does not want to rewrite British history, but only to add untold/unknown/forgotten stories that complicate the existing narrative of British history (Ibekwe 2022).

All of these works are important contributions to the democratization of historical interpretation. In some of my works, I too have problematized the dominant, conciliatory view of history by drawing on the perspective of a marginalized group (whether from the perspective of refugees, German-speaking Jews, orthodox Jews, or Roma and Sinti – e.g. Čapková 2016, 2018, 2020, 2024). What all these works have in common, however, is that they relate in some way, albeit critically, to the dominant narrative. INHIST goes a step further. As much as these contributions shake up and question an interpretation based on a one-nation-state perspective, they are still captive to its dependence. The dominant-marginalized relationship is then only a variant of the majority-minority relationship. Although this approach might seem a question purely of numbers (a minority vs majority), it reproduces ethno-racial and cultural hierarchies: the majority defines the norm, the minority is the anomaly, the deviant (Mamdani 2020). The problem of interpreting minority status arose particularly after the First World War, when the idea of democracy was, influenced by the ideas of Woodrow Wilson, linked to the idea of one-nation state (Zahra 2008). A minority is then only tolerated by the state as long as it accepts its secondary position and is sufficiently loyal in the eyes of the state (van Rahden 2023). INHIST refuses this nationalist binary view of society.

To distinguish INHIST’s approach from those above, which also use the term inclusive history, I introduce the term of polyphonic inclusivity. The inspiration for the adjective polyphonic, originally derived from music, comes from a text by the Russian literary critic Mikhail Bakhtin. When writing about Dostoevsky’s novels, he characterizes them by “[a] plurality of independent and unmerged voices and consciousnesses, a genuine polyphony of fully valid voices … What unfolds in his works is not a multitude of characters and fates in a single objective world, illuminated by a single authorial consciousness; rather a plurality of consciousnesses, with equal rights and each with its own world,

[that] combine but are not merged in the unity of the event” (Bakhtin 1984, 6). Although his text is about Dostoevsky's work, it captures key features of inclusive history as I understand it. Polyphony (1) emphasizes the agency of historical actors. In polyphony (2) each of the voices/actors is valid and equal to others, and they do not merge. Polyphony (3) is not a multitude that can be summed up in one authoritative interpretation, but a combination of full voices that relate to each other. Since one of the key characteristics of polyphonic inclusivity is agency, INHIST insists on including researchers from the communities under study in the research team. Subprojects that are not led by representatives of these communities, will utilize participatory research to understand different ways of knowing and to get insight into biased approaches (Nind 2017). In INHIST, polyphony does not only refer to the voices of Roma and Sinti, Jews and people with disabilities. Thanks to the internal diversity of their communities and through an intersectional approach, i.e. by combining different criteria and layered identities as explained below, INHIST ends up with a much larger number of voices. As J. McDonald writes in relation to the interpretation of South African history, there is a “need of a history that reflects the multiple journeys that the collective complexities, entanglements and contests that constitute its social fabric have taken on the way to the present” (McDonald 2016, 80). So polyphonic inclusivity is a newly rethought interpretation of history, one that from the outset considers the interrelated voices of different historical actors, none of which determines the dominant interpretation. This then also means that the polyphonic inclusive history approach never pretends to be complete or static (see also Barsch et al. 2020) and it requires embracing uncertainty (see also Donkersgoed 2024). It is challenging to write inclusive history of ECE in this polyphonic way, from several entangled, but often also conflicting perspectives, based on diverse archival sources and oral histories, and to focus on a region encompassing several countries. I find it, however, crucial to take a step in that direction.

Cited 
literature:

 

Bakhtin, Mikhail. 1984. Problems of Dostoevsky's Poetics. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

Barsch, Sebastian, Bettina Degner, Christoph Kühberger, and Martin Lücke. 2020. “Einleitung. Diversität im Geschichtsunterricht – Zugänge zu einer inklusiven Geschichtsdidaktik.” In Handbuch Diversität im Geschichtsunterricht. Inklusive Geschichtsdidaktik, edited by Sebastian Barsch, Bettina Degner, Christoph Kühberger, and Martin Lücke, 9–24. Frankfurt am Main; Wochenschau Verlag.

Betti, Eloisa, Leda Papastefanaki, Marica Tolomelli, and Susan Zimmermann, eds. 2022. Women, Work, and Activism. Chapters of an Inclusive History of Labor in the Long Twentieth Century. Budapest – New York: CEU Press.

Bryan-Gooden, Jahque Megan Hester, and Leah Q. Peoples. 2019. Culturally Responsive Curriculum Scorecard. New York: Metropolitan Center for Research on Equity and the Transformation of Schools, New York University.

Čapková, Kateřina. 2016. “Beyond the Assimilationist Narrative: Historiography on the Jews of the Bohemian Lands and Poland after the Second World War,” Studia Judaica 19, 2016/1 (37), 129–155.

Čapková, Kateřina. 2018. “Between Expulsion and Rescue: The Transports for German-speaking Jews of Czechoslovakia in 1946.” Holocaust and Genocide Studies 32, no. 1: 66–92.

Čapková, Kateřina. 2020. “Refugees from Nazi Germany in Czechoslovakia in the 1930s: 'In the long run, people will go down here'.” In Immigrants and Foreigners in Central and Eastern Europe during the Twentieth Century, edited by Włodzimierz Borodziej and Joachim von Puttkamer, 73–86. London – New York: Routledge.

Čapková, Kateřina. 2024. “Kontinuität der Demütigung. Bewertung der Kriegserfahrungen von Roma und Juden in der Nachkriegstschechoslowakei.” S:I.M.O.N. – Shoah: Intervention. Methods. Documentation 11, no. 1: 107–123.

Donkersgoed, Joëlla van. 2024. “Embracing Uncertainty: Utilizing the Narrated Past to Move toward a Polyvocal Inclusive History.” Global Perspectives 5, no. 1: 1–11.

Edmondson, Dylan. 2023. “Toward an Inclusive World History: Pre-Service Teachers and the Curricular Gate.” The Social Studies, 114, no.5: 205–215.

Friedländer, Saul. 1997-2007. Nazi Germany and the Jews. 2 volumes. New York: HarperCollins.

Garbarini, Alexandra, and Paul B. Jaskot, eds. 2018. New Approaches to an Integrated History of the Holocaust: Social History, Representation, Theory. Evanston: Northwestern University Press.

Ibekwe, Desiree. 2022 “David Olusoga Wants Britain to Face Its Past. All of It.” The New York Times (online), February 7.

Mamdani, Mahmood. 2020. Neither Settler nor Native. The Making and Unmaking of Permanent Minorities. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.

McDonald, Jared. 2016. “Inclusive Histories for Inclusive Futures: Interactions and Entanglements then and now.” Yesterday & Today 11, no. 15: 66–83.

Naidu-Silverman, Ereshnee. 2020. “Re-imaging an Inclusive People’s History.” International Public History, 3, no. 2: 1–3.

Nind, Melanie. 2017. “The Practical Wisdom of Inclusive Research.” Qualitative Research 17, no. 3: 278–288.

Olusoga, David. 2016. Black and British. A Forgotten History. London: Macmillan.

Otele, Olivette. 2020. African Europeans. An Untold History. London: Hurst & Company.

Rahden, Till van. 2023. “Minderheit und Mehrheit. Vom Traum demokratischer Gleichheit zum Phantasma nationaler Reinheit.” In Mobilität und Differenzierung. Zur Konstruktion von Unterschieden und Zugehörigkeiten in der europäischen Neuzeit, edited by Sarah Panter, Johannes Paulmann and Thomas Weller, 253–284. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.

Rutar, Sabine (ed.). 2014. Beyond the Balkans. Towards an Inclusive History of Southeastern Europe. Vienna: Lit Verlag.

Weuffen, Sara. 2022. “‘You’d be surprised how some people probably feel uncomfortable’: the compliance-resistance continuum of planning integrated Australian History curricula.” Teacher Development 26, no. 2: 221–239.

Wiese, Christian, and Paul Betts (eds.). 2011. Years of Persecution, years of Extermination: Saul Friedlander and the Future of Holocaust Studies. Continuum.

Worthington, Lea, Rachel Clare Donaldson, and John W. White (eds.). 2021. Challenging History. Race, Equity, and the Practice of Public History. Columbia, SC: The University of South Carolina Press.

Zahra, Tara. 2008. “The ‘Minority Problem’ and National Classification in the French and Czechoslovak Borderlands.” Contemporary European History 17, no. 2: 137–165.